← Human perception

Motion Clarity & Motion Smoothness. Two sides of the same coin.

Why smoothness and clarity aren't the same thing: smooth pursuit, sample-and-hold persistence blur, backlight strobing, and how refresh rate improves both.

4 min read

Motion smoothness and motion clarity are two things you’ll hear about quite often when looking at monitors. They both affect how movement looks, and increasing refresh rate can improve both, which makes them a common victim of conflation. You can think of smoothness as fluidity, and clarity as fidelity.

Some simple biomechanics

Let’s start off with some simple biomechanics to understand what’s what.

When you track a moving object, your eyes obviously move along with it. This is called smooth pursuit. The idea is to keep the object’s image relatively steady on your retina, particularly near the centre where you can see fine detail best. If someone walks past you and you follow their face with your eyes, you’re doing exactly this. The person is moving, your eyes are moving, but their face stays relatively steady in your vision. That is what helps you actually see their features while they move.

A monitor makes this a little complicated, because movement on a screen is made up of individual frames. Each frame shows the object in one position, and the next frame shows it a little further along. Your eyes follow the movement those frames create, but the monitor is still showing you a series of stationary images.

Sample-and-hold and persistence blur

Most monitors today keep each of those images visible until the next one replaces it, and this is called sample-and-hold. It’s how both LCDs and OLEDs normally work. At 240Hz, assuming you’re getting 240 unique frames per second, each frame stays visible for about 4.17 milliseconds. That sounds like basically nothing, but your eyes can move quite a fair amount in that time, especially when you’re tracking vigorously.

Now, in those 4.17 milliseconds, your eyes keep moving because they’re following the object, but the image on the monitor stays in the same spot. As your eyes move, the light from that stationary image lands at different positions on your retina. All that light then gets spread out across it and is combined by your visual system in a very short period, which makes it look blurry. This is referred to as persistence blur. You could have the world’s sharpest image, but the interaction between your moving eyes and the held image makes it look blurry.

Hold times and motion clarity

This is where hold times come in. Meaning the longer the image stays visible while your eyes move, the more it can spread across your retina. Shorten that time and you slash the amount of blur, making the image crisp once more. That’s essentially what motion clarity is.

This also explains why an OLED can still have some pretty bad motion blur despite its basically instant response times. It can finish the transition extremely quickly, but then holds that image for the rest of the frame. Your eyes are still moving during that hold, so you still get persistence blur. On an LCD, slower pixel transitions can add even more smearing on top of it.

Backlight strobing

Backlight strobing (DyAc, ULMB, G-SYNC Pulsar) greatly reduces the time you actually see each frame. On an LCD, the backlight quickly flashes the image, then turns off for the remainder. The pixels might still be holding their values, but you can only see them while the backlight is on. Your eyes continue moving through the dark interval without receiving more light from that image, which hugely reduces the opportunity for it to smear across your retina. Shorter the flash, lower the persistence blur.

The ViewSonic XG2431

Let’s take an example: the ViewSonic XG2431. It’s a 240Hz IPS monitor. You might associate max motion clarity with TN monitors, but strobing implementations matter a lot.

Its PureXP modes let you shorten the time each frame is visible, with Ultra using a slightly shorter flash than Light. It also gets dimmer, like a lot dimmer. That’s because you hardly have an image to look at in the first place, which kills luminance; we’re not looking at brightness figures here though.

Motion smoothness

Let’s move on to smoothness now.

Say something moves 960 pixels across your screen in one second. At 60 FPS, it moves 16 pixels between frames. At 240 FPS, it moves four pixels between frames. It still covers the same distance in the same amount of time, but now you get to see four times as many positions along the way. The gap between each position is smaller, and so is the time between seeing them. That gives your visual system a closer approximation of continuous movement, making it look more fluid.

You can get a very rough idea of this by moving your cursor quickly across the screen while keeping your gaze around the centre. You may see several separated cursor afterimages along its path. A higher refresh rate brings those positions closer together. This is why making motion clearer doesn’t simply make it smoother. If you run a monitor at 240Hz and shorten each flash to 1ms, you still have 240 frames / positions being shown every second. Each position becomes easier to see clearly while tracking, but the distance and time between those positions stay the same without any increase in smoothness.

How higher refresh rates improve both

Another interesting tidbit is that a higher refresh rate (and FPS) can actually improve both simultaneously, given the pixel response times are instant and there’s no overshoot. Try 480 unique frames on a 480Hz monitor, and you now get twice as many positions along the same movement. The distance and time between them are halved, dropping from about 4.17ms to 2.08ms. So you improve smoothness by showing more positions, and improve clarity by holding each one for less time.

Conclusion

In conclusion, don’t conflate smoothness and clarity. While they may be two sides of the same coin, they’re still their own, individual topics and perceptual mechanisms. Account for both, and all will be okay.