Imagine two slices of bread, except one is a good bit larger than the other. Now get some peanut butter and spread the same amount equally across both. The smaller slice gets a nice, thick layer, while the larger one ends up with barely any PB on it. That’s PPI. Your resolution is the PB, and your monitor is the bread.
PPI (Pixels Per Inch) measures the density of pixels in a display. A 24 inch 1080p monitor has roughly 92 PPI, while a 27 inch 1080p monitor drops to around 82 PPI. Both have exactly the same number of pixels, except they’re spread across different sizes. As pixel density decreases, you start seeing individual pixels. I’m sure you understand why that would look bad.
For regular desktop use, I generally wouldn’t recommend going beyond 25 inches at 1080p or 27 inches at 1440p. A 27 inch 1440p monitor nets you around 109 PPI, while stretching that resolution to 32 inches brings you back down to roughly 92 PPI, the same density as 24 inch 1080p. With 4K, you’ve got considerably more room to work with. Even a 42 inch 4K display manages around 105 PPI, making the resolution suitable for lots of different sizes.
Viewing distance matters too. A 55 inch 4K television has a relatively low PPI compared to a desktop monitor, but it can still look pretty sharp when you’re sitting several metres away. When you sit further away, each pixel becomes tiny to your eyes. This means that pixel density alone doesn’t really determine perceived sharpness. Pixels per degree (PPD), which factors in distance, gets much closer. Also, the benefits of increasing resolution and subsequently PPI eventually start tapering off, making the additional detail difficult to make out at your usual viewing distance.
Personally, and entirely subjectively, I prefer 24 inch 1440p monitors. At roughly 122 PPI, they look clearly sharper than 27 inch 1440p displays, while remaining a good size for general use. That plus I get to play at higher FPS compared to 4K, which is nice.
There’s only so far you can spread the PB before you’re basically eating plain bread. It’s yummier when you don’t.