You’ve probably heard someone say that humans can only see 60 FPS, or that anything above 144Hz is basically pointless. These bogus, misinformed claims usually come from taking one particular limit of human vision and applying it to everything else. Seeing a light flicker, seeing movement look more fluid, and seeing detail during movement are different things.
People have demonstrated the ability to reliably perceive visual artefacts at frequencies above 10kHz. Crazy, no?
Flicker fusion and the supposed limits
Let’s start off with flicker fusion to understand where some of these claims come from.
Take a light and repeatedly turn it on and off. At low frequencies, you can obviously see it flashing. Increase the frequency and eventually the flashes become difficult to distinguish, until the light looks steady. This is called the critical flicker fusion threshold.
The exact threshold depends on the viewing conditions and the person, so even here, assigning everyone one number is already quite questionable. The bigger problem is assuming that once the light looks steady, there’s nothing else about its behaviour that your eyes can pick up.
A study by Davis, Hsieh and Lee demonstrated this quite nicely. With a spatially uniform stimulus, sensitivity to flicker dropped away around 65Hz. Introduce a sharp edge into the image, though, and all ten participants could see artefacts above 200Hz. The median threshold sat around 500Hz, while several participants reported seeing them above 800Hz. The image itself changed how high the detectable frequency could go.
Put simply, a limit measured by looking at a uniform patch of light tells you about that one, particular situation. Change the image or even just how your eyes move across it, and you can get a vastly different result.
Eye movements and the phantom array effect
Alongside smooth pursuit, which we discussed in the motion clarity article, your eyes also make quick movements called saccades. These happen when you shift your gaze from one thing to another. They can be extremely fast, and that speed allows something pretty interesting to happen when you look across a flashing light.
During the movement, each flash reaches your eyes at a slightly different eye position. The light therefore lands at different positions on your retina, producing a series of separate images. You might perceive a row of dots, lines, grids - even though there’s only one light source. This is called the phantom array effect, which quickly exposes whether or not a light is actually steady.
Visual acuity matters here quite a bit, since not everyone can detect changes as well as the next person.
What studies actually found
This was tested with a narrow, very bright light source. Subjects made saccades across it and later compared pairs of presentations. One presentation flashed at a frequency between 1kHz and 11kHz, while the other used 60kHz as a reference.
The average threshold was around 6kHz, but a few people could reliably distinguish 11kHz from the 60kHz reference via phantom array. That means light changing 11,000 times per second could still produce a visible difference under their test conditions.
Conclusion
In conclusion, don’t assign human vision a fixed FPS cap. We have experimental evidence of visible effects above 10kHz. Besides, we don’t even see in frames. What a dumb comparison.
And yes, you will notice the jump from your 240Hz monitor to a 360Hz one. Yes, even 360Hz to 500Hz. And yes, even 500Hz to 560Hz, or even 720Hz. If you hit those framerates, of course.