Picking a monitor would be pretty easy if you could trust the box. Sadly, you can’t. Resolution, size and refresh rate are fine, but the rest of the spec sheet is written by a marketing team whose job is to sell you the thing.
Two monitors with near identical spec sheets can be night and day once you sit in front of them. So how do you tell them apart before spending your money? Proper measurements, from people who know what they’re doing. Here’s how I go about it, and what a monitor has to get through before it ends up on my recommendation list.
The Spec Sheet // Fiction
Let’s start off with what to ignore, which is most of it.
The “1ms” response time is the big one. It’s measured in whatever mode makes the number smallest in a tiny part of the screen, under lab conditions usually with overdrive cranked so high the image is covered in overshoot, and it tells you basically nothing about how the monitor performs in real world use. I’ve already gone through why in the response times article, so I’ll leave it there.
DisplayHDR 400 is next. It’s the lowest HDR tier and it doesn’t mandate local dimming, so on most LCDs it just means a bright-ish SDR monitor with a cool sticker on it. The plain 400 badge is…not worth much.
To make matters worse, there’s the naming. “Fast IPS”, “Nano IPS” and “Rapid VA” are brand names, nothing more, and two “Fast IPS” monitors can be miles apart. Even the panel type itself only gives you a rough idea of what to expect (read more in Monitor Panels 101).
OLEDs have their own trap. The same “240Hz QD-OLED” label can mean a full brightness panel or a cut down Edge panel capped at 400 nits in HDR, and the box won’t tell you which. OLED Generations, Explained has the full table if you want to check.
So if the box doesn’t tell you much, what does?
Reviews // Non-Fiction
Reviews, from someone who’s actually put the monitor through proper testing. Not every review counts, though. An unboxing, a “first impressions” video or a five star Amazon rating tells you the monitor turned on and the person liked it, not much objective information to be had there.
A review worth trusting measures things. Response times and overshoot with proper equipment, brightness and colour with a colourimeter. Opinions on top are fine (mine are very opinionated, after all), but they’re only a garnish to the dish in its entirety. Reviewers should also show their working, so you know what “good” means in their charts, and it should test the modes you’ll actually use: every overdrive setting, more than one refresh rate, with and without VRR.
The ones I rely on most are TFTCentral, RTINGS, Monitors Unboxed (the TechSpot write-ups if you don’t feel like watching a video), PCMonitors, Aperture Grille, the folks over at Bilibili, KitGuru, Club386, Blur Busters, DisplayNinja, and a few others I’m sure I’m unjustifiably forgetting.
Motion // Where LCDs Live or Die
For a gaming monitor, this is usually the first thing I check, and the first place a lot of LCDs fall apart. I’ve covered the details in the response times article, so here’s the short version.
Look at the full response time heatmap, not just the average at the top, since a handful of slow dark transitions is all it takes to cause smearing. The opposite can also be true, making monitors seem worse than they really are. Check or calculate refresh rate compliance, and check overshoot across the overdrive modes because the fastest mode is very often not the best one. Ideally, a single overdrive mode looks good across the whole refresh range. Switching modes every time your framerate dips gets…very annoying.
If the review has some form of pursuit photos (a camera tracking a moving pattern, like the UFO tests), look at those too. They’re the closest thing to what your eyes actually see, and they make smearing and overshoot obvious at a glance.
Contrast & HDR // The Small Print
This is where spec sheets turn to mush.
For LCDs, typical native contrast is 1000:1 for IPS and TN, and anywhere from 2500-4000:1 for VA. Some variants may have more or less.
For SDR, check full screen brightness, not peak. 250 nits is plenty for most rooms, but if you’re sat next to a window you’ll probably want more. HDR is a bit more complicated in general, so you should look at the whole smorgasbord of window sizes (1%, 10%, 25%, 50%, 100%). Some reviews also measure actual HDR scenes rather than just test windows, which is closer to what you’ll see and way more valuable info.
EOTF tracking is something I often see people forget about. Put simply, it’s how closely the monitor sticks to the brightness the content asks for. Bad tracking means HDR that’s too dark, too bright or washed out, and you could use the Sun as the peak but it’d still look bad. With MiniLED, don’t get too hung up on zone count either (though more is always better, especially on smaller screens). Look at blooming examples, especially small bright things on dark backgrounds, like your cursor.
Colour // More Isn’t Better
Two separate things tend to get lumped together here. Gamut is the range of colours a monitor can show, usually given as coverage of sRGB, DCI-P3 and sometimes Rec. 2020. Accuracy is whether it shows the colours it’s actually asked to, usually given as Delta E (ΔE). Below 2 is hard to tell apart from perfect, and somewhere above 3 you might start noticing.
But the thing is, most of what you look at is made for sRGB, and if you show that on a wide gamut monitor without any correction, everything gets oversaturated. Reds turn neon, skin tones go orange. Some people like it, and that’s a-okay, but it isn’t accurate.
So check whether the monitor has a usable sRGB mode, and whether that mode still lets you adjust brightness. Plenty of monitors lock it, which makes the mode rather pointless. If there’s no hardware clamp at all, Windows ACM or GPU side fixes like NVIDIA’s Color Accuracy Mode or AMD’s driver can work around it. Not dealbreaking, of course, but definitely something to note.
Everything Else // Not on the Box
This is where a lot of monitors that look great on paper fall over, because none of it ever makes the spec sheet.
Uniformity varies unit to unit: backlight bleed and clouding on LCDs, near black banding on some OLEDs. One review is a hint, so don’t treat it as gospel, and the grey banding article is a good example of how far this can go. VRR flicker is another one, especially on OLEDs in dark scenes when your framerate jumps around. Some reviews test it, plenty don’t.
Text clarity comes down to subpixel layout and pixel density. It matters a lot if you work on the monitor and much less if you only game (more on that in How Important Is PPI?). Coating is honestly personal preference, as much as people like to say otherwise. Input lag is a nothingburger, so forget about it.
Lastly, the boring stuff. Some companies are nice and push fixes through firmware updates, and some never touch a monitor again after launch, so check whether reviewers or people online in general mention known issues and whether a later revision fixed them.
My List // Where It All Ends Up
All of that is taken into account before I decide to recommend something. Some recs are speculative, either using intuition (sorry) or it’s a monitor using a panel that’s already proven elsewhere but hasn’t been reviewed itself yet. There’s no ranking by panel type either. Because that’s stupid.
If something isn’t on the list, it’s most likely not worth it. Or I just haven’t seen it yet. Feel free to send me stuff :)
Conclusion
So, in conclusion, ignore the box and find a couple reviews that aren’t slop. Of course, not everything matters to everyone. Someone playing competitive shooters and someone editing photos all day should be looking at completely different things. So check what’s relevant to YOU.
And if you can’t be bothered with any of that? Well, that’s what my list is for.